D'oh!

A DI Wire headline today states that "MVP REIT Reports 94 Percent Increase In Year-Over-Year Revenues."  Amazing! Stupendous! Fantastic! Misleading!  The REIT was raising and investing money over this period, so a 94% revenue increase needs more context.  A REIT raising equity and borrowing money to buy properties better be increasing revenue. Year-over-year financial performance for any investment in the midst of raising and investing capital is non-comparable.

Let's take a look at some of MVP REIT's other year-over-year financial points of interest from the same financial statement along with sample headlines:

• Assets increased 59% from $81 million to $129 million.  "MVP REIT's Total Asset Skyrocket 59%"
• Debt increased 75% from $25 million to $44 million.  "Burdened:  MVP REIT's Debt Leaps 75%"
• MVP's Net Loss for the six months ended June 30, 2016 was ($2,131,000) compared to a Net loss of ($1,572,000) for the six months ended June 30, 2015, a drop of 39%.  "Oops, MVP REIT's Net Loss Moves In Wrong Direction, Dropping 39%"
• MVP's Cash From Operations for the six months ended June 30, 2016 was ($1,159,000) compared to Cash From Operations of ($1,347,000) for the six months ended June 30, 2015, an improvement of 14%.  "MVP REIT Slows Hemorrhage of Operating Cash"

All the headlines are right, and all are misleading.  Only when MVP REIT has several quarters of fully invested operations will period-over-period comparisons be relevant.  One point that is true about MVP REIT, and that is not obfuscation, is that it is a small REIT.  It only raised $97 million in equity in its offering and has $129 million in total assets.